The “What Why What” Formula For Nurturing True Fans

In 2021, bloggers often STRUGGLE to get page views–let alone REAL fans that continue to follow them for months and years.

It’s a busy internet ????

The “What Why What” formula contains the bare minimum of blog “branding” that you absolutely NEED to emphasis if you want to attract long-term fans and readers.

This is a simple copywriting lesson that’ll help you turn random website visitors into people that follow you.

Want to know the real reason behind this post?

To help me save time on blog reviews.

I’ve reviewed over 1,000 blogs over the past 5 years–and every single blog I’ve looked at runs into the same problem.

They lack the essential explanation behind “what why what.”

So I’m finally just putting my answer into a blog post format to hand to people ????

So let’s dig into what the heck that means, and why it’s important.

The goal: to collect loyal, trusting, raving fans.

And we want to nurture them starting with random website visitors (i.e. new traffic).

Got it?

People come to your brand from a tweet, pin, click in Google, etc–and you nurture them to raving fans who buy your products and click your affiliate links. The “what why what” conquers the FIRST step in that journey before people bail on your blog

Without nailing this, that journey will never take place for most blog visitors.

1 – “What” is your blog about?

If the name of your blog is “Personal Finance for Dummies” or “Problogger,” people might get a great idea.

But what if you’re domain/brand name is your name?

Or something clever but obscure that explains nothing? (Think

What if your name is Busy Budgeter, but you also talk about multiple sub-topics that aren’t budgeting?

Don’t you think you should explicitly tell people EXACTLY what you blog about?

rosemarie busy budgeter homepage
She told us, explicitly, WHAT her blog is about

FYI that’s Rosemarie, founder of Busy Budgeter, a $1M+ blog. Here’s her story!

Your job as a brand-builder and true-fan-magnet is to inform new website visitors EXACTLY what your blog and brand is about. What you teach, share, and sell. Make it easy for people to learn this information.

Where is this most important?

Your homepage, and possibly your about page. Tell people what you do.

Moving on.

2 – “Why” should we follow you–rather than your competitors?

So your name is Bobby and you started a personal finance website called “Millennial Money Man.”


But there are 1,823 other personal finance blogs out there.

Rockstar Finance says over 1,800 personal finance blogs in their directory…

Why should people follow Bobby as opposed to everybody else?

Bobby sharing “why” people should trust his content and follow him

Apply everything I’m saying to your own niche FYI.

There are tons of other blogs like yours.

There are two main ways to convince visitors why they need to follow YOU: Authority and your unique story.

  1. Authority = People want to know that YOU know what the heck you’re talking about.
  2. Your unique story = something none of your competitors have.

Bobby’s story above is that he paid off $40k of student loans over 18 months on a teacher’s salary.

While there are loads of similar stories now among finance bloggers–there were far fewer when Bobby started his blog, and it allowed him to stand out and make people say “wow.”

Home page, about page, sidebars, email opt-ins. Show people why.

Most of DYEB’s “why” is my story.

  1. I’ve started over 45+ online businesses and blogs, failed a lot, and have a ton of stories for learning to share.
  2. I might actually be OBSESSED with blogging and online business. My passion for this helps me stand out.
  3. I quit a cushy job to be broke for a while and make this whole online business thing work.
  4. I made $18k in my first year, and on track to triple that in year 2.

3 – “What’s” in it for me (a new website visitor)?

The old “WIIFM” thing:

What’s In It For Me?”

Seriously though. What’s it in for me to read your blog post? Literally, what am I going to get?

Knowledge? Laughter? Commiseration?

What’s it in for me to opt-in to your email list–especially since I’m on 10+ other newsletters in your niche?

What do I get?

Tell people, in the most explicit of terms, exactly what they will get out of being a follower of [your-blog-name].

problogger email opt in
Tell them what’s in store if they stick around.

Go back and remember our goal.

Repeat after me.

My job as a blogger is to turn cold website traffic (new visitors), into loyal repeat visitors, fans, and customers.

You don’t make tons of money from your blog from brand-new website visitors. You make them over time from loyal fans.

Sharing your “what why what” is the very first step to turning first-time visitors to repeat visitors.

judgment-free finance and friend-making. Their core purpose attracts their core audience.

Random website visitors need to know

  1. what on earth your platform talks about (specifically)
  2. why they should follow you rather than other similar blogs
  3. what they’re going to GET out of being a follower.

So tell them, in as few words as possible, as quickly as possible, all across your blog.

Go forth and nurture true fans.

But before you do, drop me a comment and say hello below!

Keep Reading

15 Responses

  1. Hi Pete,

    thanks for sharing this tactic. I’ve tried to implement it and I’ve also offered some freebies to gain subscribers. The only problem is my unsubscribe rate. People sign up, download the freebie, then unsubscribe the same day.
    Any tips on how to prevent/fix this?

    1. 1 – don’t fret about unsubscribes. They’ll always happen.

      2 – Are you sending multiple emails the same day? Ask yourself WHY people might be unsubbing.

      3 – Focus on creating long-term value, and literally tell them why they should stay connected with you. This one’s tricky.

  2. Great article, Pete! When I post the show notes of your interview on my podcast, I will definitely link to this article. You gave me this advice on the episode and here it’s all drawn out. Thanks! Very helpful.

    1. Ding ding ding!

      Probably the #1 reason bloggers quit in year one. No “perceived traction.” I.e. nothing to make them feel validated for their efforts.

  3. Love this Pete! Going to go through and apply what you said here (and in your rant video haha!)

    Any advice on applying this to a travel blog specifically? A lot of the advice I see are often for blogs that offer online services, such as the personal finance blogs listed above, it sometimes doesn’t translate as directly to a travel blog…or I’m just really dumb haha

    1. First, you’re not dumb.

      Second, I think it definitely still applies to ANYBODY with an audience.

      What does your audience want/need from your travel blog? How do you help/teach/entertain people?

      Travel tips? Tips related to specific destinations? Entertainment because they live vicariously through you?

  4. Thanks Pete for this awesome formula. I had implemented this in some form unconsciously but needed the What-why-what structure to make it crisp.

    BTW I am also including links to some of my popular articles within the “What” block in addition to featured.(authority).
    1) Are too many links distracting for a first time visitor?
    2) Is it appropriate that some of these links are to Product review articles focused on solving a problem? They do contain affiliate links. Or does it look like I am trying for a sign-up too early before courtship?

    1. 1 – Depends on what “too many” is. I just suggest helping them find what they’re looking for, i.e. a “start here” format.

      Looking for X? Try this post.

      Looking for Y? Try this post.

      ETc 🙂

      2 – Yup! Absolutely.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.